The COVID Economy: Where Are We Now?
Diane Swonk discusses where we’ve been and possibly where we’re going as the economy braces for more impacts from COVID-19 with Richard Green. Tracing the line back from January 2020 to the Fall, she overlays her concerns about COVID’s long term impacts on Millennials, Gen Z, women in the workforce, and the ever-widening gaps in racial disparities. Green offers supporting evidence as well as questions regarding how the supply chain might change. Swonk insists throughout that the course of the virus is the course of the economy regardless of government intervention.
Please note this automated transcription may contain errors.
00:01:55.080 --> 00:01:59.340
richardgreen: it is a
00:01:59.580 --> 00:02:02.550
richardgreen: real treat to have our guest for this week. Diane
00:02:02.550 --> 00:02:03.180
00:02:04.080 --> 00:02:09.810
richardgreen: Diane is currently chief economist of Grant Thornton. She's been chief economist and a number of places.
00:02:10.650 --> 00:02:16.560
richardgreen: We first got to know each other when we were on advisory board Chicago fed and that's where she is joining us from today.
00:02:16.560 --> 00:02:17.280
00:02:19.320 --> 00:02:30.060
richardgreen: And the thing about Diane is while many of us are really good at our silos Diane is one of the few people I know we can put all the pieces together. Come up with a coherent narrative about
00:02:30.450 --> 00:02:46.620
richardgreen: What's going on in the economy, thinking about the individual pieces and so she's had a remarkable track record for seeing what was going to happen to the macro economy and us today and it's great to have you with us. Thanks for being here.
00:02:47.220 --> 00:02:48.300
Diane Swonk: Good to be here. Richard
00:02:49.350 --> 00:02:50.820
richardgreen: So I want to start with.
00:02:51.300 --> 00:02:53.520
richardgreen: A question that I asked everybody who comes on.
00:02:53.580 --> 00:02:56.220
richardgreen: To our class which is just if you could, in two or three minutes.
00:02:56.250 --> 00:02:58.290
richardgreen: Talk about how you got to where you are.
00:02:58.290 --> 00:02:58.680
00:02:58.980 --> 00:02:59.610
richardgreen: A little bit about your
00:03:01.470 --> 00:03:05.460
Diane Swonk: Well, given my career's real long now it's hard to put it into two to three minutes.
00:03:06.480 --> 00:03:13.200
Diane Swonk: I actually started out, I took an economics class as a fluke at University of Michigan as an undergraduate.
00:03:13.440 --> 00:03:29.880
Diane Swonk: And right before I took the class. I got a call from my then boyfriend over the winter break that someone had burned down the oldest building on campus, which was the economics department and then hey, was an eye taking economics and I took economics and
00:03:30.960 --> 00:03:32.730
Diane Swonk: The professor was absolutely horrible.
00:03:33.270 --> 00:03:34.320
richardgreen: It was, it was one of these
00:03:34.320 --> 00:03:40.590
Diane Swonk: Big 300 room lecture halls, but the TA was fabulous and
00:03:41.670 --> 00:03:46.050
Diane Swonk: I was the only woman in the class and didn't know that that was an issue until later.
00:03:46.260 --> 00:03:57.270
Diane Swonk: And my career, but it was the easiest thing I ever did. I mean I got there, and all of a sudden, I'm like, wow, this is what my brain was wired to do I'm you know I'm dyslexic, Richard. So you know I can't
00:03:57.630 --> 00:04:09.450
Diane Swonk: Do get numbers flipped. I can't dial a phone number, but I can do calculus in my head. So the math part was easy, but also it was so much a combination of everything that I had grown up with
00:04:09.750 --> 00:04:16.530
Diane Swonk: I grew up in the Detroit area during the train wreck of the 1970s. Yes, I am. That old but I'm still younger than you, Richard.
00:04:16.890 --> 00:04:18.300
richardgreen: I always will be.
00:04:18.930 --> 00:04:28.350
Diane Swonk: I know I remember you were telling me that you were upset when you met me because you were no longer the youngest person in the room. But I think, neither of us.
00:04:28.680 --> 00:04:29.670
richardgreen: Wanted. I was
00:04:29.700 --> 00:04:32.490
richardgreen: I was teasing when I said that. But it was mostly a true
00:04:32.670 --> 00:04:34.740
richardgreen: But it was actually a true statement at the time.
00:04:35.970 --> 00:04:42.810
Diane Swonk: I know. And I was, I was in my 20s. So we've known each other a long time but anyways.
00:04:43.590 --> 00:04:54.240
Diane Swonk: So that love of economics, the intuitive nature of it that it explained that we didn't. I didn't have to grow up in the train wreck. I did, or my bathroom went into poverty.
00:04:54.510 --> 00:05:05.250
Diane Swonk: And my dad was getting a new car every 60 days in the auto industry and we lived in the same neighborhood and she was having to dig up her backyard to plant food for family and had to go to work.
00:05:06.300 --> 00:05:14.880
Diane Swonk: At a minimum wage job. The time to try to supplement our family income at 16 years of age. So growing up in that train wreck and realizing it didn't have to be that way.
00:05:15.360 --> 00:05:26.370
Diane Swonk: I mean, this was like the world is fell in my lap that then I started out working for the chairman's office at 23 years old, but I did an accelerated program masters and undergraduate
00:05:26.940 --> 00:05:34.560
Diane Swonk: And they said they would pay for a PhD and then they didn't sense that they paid for an MBA. So I did that. Instead, I always got my education paid for but
00:05:35.700 --> 00:05:42.960
Diane Swonk: It was. And that's when I went to Chicago was working as well but starting out and working 19 years in finance in a large
00:05:43.980 --> 00:05:57.690
Diane Swonk: Money center bank was really quite an extraordinary experience but also it was, you know, always working for the, the CEO. I mean, starting at 23 and working for the CEO and you know what set my career was
00:05:58.440 --> 00:06:02.310
Diane Swonk: One of the easiest forecasts I've ever made. And that was, at the time I was
00:06:02.580 --> 00:06:10.740
Diane Swonk: Had a specialty in the auto industry because they said you're from Michigan and, of course, my father worked in the auto industry and I haven't worked in print walking production plan, since I was a toddler so
00:06:11.010 --> 00:06:17.490
Diane Swonk: I had an intimate knowledge that I didn't realize I had, but I also then became a regional economist
00:06:17.850 --> 00:06:35.880
Diane Swonk: And I did an analysis that said the Midwest at the time would rise like a phoenix out of its own ashes of the rust belt, and it did and that set me on a career that I'm still doing today. And part of the reason that it put me on this career track was at a mentor who told me
00:06:37.140 --> 00:06:43.080
Diane Swonk: I want you to be the most famous economists, you know in in your area in the country.
00:06:43.590 --> 00:06:55.170
Diane Swonk: And I want you to be in the process so that we can move strategy that we were doing internal analysis because we're using the process as a mechanism to change the views of our senior management and
00:06:56.040 --> 00:07:04.890
Diane Swonk: That was why I started doing so much media and then of course we also got the brand equity from that media stuff but
00:07:05.580 --> 00:07:13.650
Diane Swonk: He never he's once said to me, it wasn't altruistic when I mentored you you made me look good and so that helped my career, but he also
00:07:14.280 --> 00:07:23.670
Diane Swonk: You know what I learned along the way was one, your job is always to make the person above you look better and to there was
00:07:24.360 --> 00:07:35.280
Diane Swonk: I might not have been the sharpest knife in the drawer of economists and I didn't do the same kind of research, but my gift is to translate what the economy means to a lot of people and connect the dots in ways that
00:07:35.790 --> 00:07:41.730
Diane Swonk: Resonate with them and make it real. And I think that's what my career is about
00:07:42.840 --> 00:07:46.650
richardgreen: Yeah, I think the connecting the dots part is critically important. And that's why I said it.
00:07:46.650 --> 00:07:50.400
richardgreen: It's, it's more than translation. It's your ability to see the big
00:07:50.400 --> 00:07:55.680
richardgreen: Picture and put it together. That's always been so impressive about you. So
00:07:55.740 --> 00:08:08.460
Diane Swonk: Let's my dyslexia to, you know, we tend to see the world. We see the endgame. And we see it all. And it's a gift. And it's also occurs because when you can see things. It's a hard sometimes you don't like the picture you see
00:08:09.690 --> 00:08:25.920
richardgreen: So let's now put that talent of yours to use and let's go back. If you don't mind to January of this year, so we know we knew Kobe was happening in China we hadn't recorded our first case yet.
00:08:25.950 --> 00:08:35.340
richardgreen: In the US, and I know this are really hardly could go do because nine months ago now seems like nine years. Nine decades, I don't know, it's
00:08:36.120 --> 00:08:36.300
00:08:38.010 --> 00:08:40.500
richardgreen: But, but, but if you could try to put yourself.
00:08:40.500 --> 00:08:41.790
richardgreen: Back in that place.
00:08:41.850 --> 00:08:45.510
richardgreen: And tell us what you were seeing them and then I want to
00:08:45.630 --> 00:08:49.080
richardgreen: Of course, follow up and talk about what we have seen since
00:08:51.030 --> 00:08:56.580
Diane Swonk: Well, we were coming off of the year of the trade wars and we're trying to cut a deal with China.
00:08:57.210 --> 00:09:02.610
Diane Swonk: The phase one deal with China, the trade wars had already taken a toll on investment.
00:09:03.120 --> 00:09:15.810
Diane Swonk: And there is concerned about that. But, you know, as long as we had called a ceasefire of sorts, on the trade wars, we thought we'd make it through and have another good year in 2020
00:09:16.350 --> 00:09:31.230
Diane Swonk: Because we had significant employment momentum. And finally, the economy was finally delivering to lowest wage workers and we were seeing those wages finally accelerate in a way that it hadn't during until the very latter
00:09:31.770 --> 00:09:50.310
Diane Swonk: Stages of the expansion. And so that was something that was to embrace it was hard, knowing that at three and a half percent unemployment rates. We're still seeing homelessness rise, which you see in your own backyard. But that was the economy was still doing fine.
00:09:51.720 --> 00:09:54.030
richardgreen: So I think what you said is
00:09:54.060 --> 00:09:55.110
richardgreen: That was so striking is
00:09:55.170 --> 00:09:56.640
richardgreen: Seeing wages. Finally, at the bottom.
00:09:56.640 --> 00:10:02.220
richardgreen: Of the distribution increased. One of the things here in California is, of course, we now have a
00:10:02.220 --> 00:10:07.260
richardgreen: $15 an hour minimum wage and people were very worried about the employment effect of that.
00:10:07.620 --> 00:10:12.660
richardgreen: But in coastal California. It's pretty much irrelevant. Now if you go to mit.or I shouldn't say now, but it was
00:10:12.660 --> 00:10:13.620
richardgreen: Irrelevant back in
00:10:13.650 --> 00:10:14.700
richardgreen: January, February.
00:10:15.090 --> 00:10:21.570
richardgreen: If you would go to it in and out or McDonalds and see what they were hiring for something bucks an hour plus benefits so that $15
00:10:21.600 --> 00:10:23.430
Diane Swonk: An hour West even finding the time
00:10:23.940 --> 00:10:26.370
richardgreen: So I think that's a really important
00:10:27.060 --> 00:10:28.410
richardgreen: Point. I'm sorry. Go ahead.
00:10:28.890 --> 00:10:39.060
Diane Swonk: Well, yeah, to add on to that. I mean we tracked really closely the changes so effectively the minimum wage across the country, even though it hasn't been raised at the federal level, the
00:10:39.750 --> 00:10:54.900
Diane Swonk: Really started in 2014 elections changes at the local level and state level on and we've seen it in 2016 and 2018 elections that the shifts were happening at the minimum wage pushing up the minimum wage and stages and
00:10:54.960 --> 00:11:02.820
Diane Swonk: In fact, the research on it has showed it had very little impact no impact on employment at the time because
00:11:03.090 --> 00:11:12.360
Diane Swonk: labor markets, we're tightening and it was raising wages into a tightening labor market also I think it really made a difference that many of those minimum wage hikes that were occurring were crying.
00:11:12.690 --> 00:11:21.780
Diane Swonk: Based on local cost, rather than just one minimum wage across the country, because of course $15 an hour means something different in you know in some place like
00:11:22.230 --> 00:11:28.020
Diane Swonk: Me or Mississippi to be very pointed than it does in New York or Los Angeles.
00:11:29.460 --> 00:11:36.540
richardgreen: So okay, so now let's move forward a little bit and tell us. So when did you start saying to yourself, oh my god, this is going to be
00:11:36.540 --> 00:11:36.960
00:11:38.430 --> 00:11:38.940
Diane Swonk: Well,
00:11:39.030 --> 00:11:39.390
richardgreen: Can you
00:11:40.830 --> 00:11:45.750
Diane Swonk: Yeah, I have. There's one when they started to close down move on.
00:11:47.910 --> 00:11:54.750
Diane Swonk: I have a very close friend who has adopted two children from China and her son has moved back to China and had his family there.
00:11:55.320 --> 00:11:59.730
Diane Swonk: And he went to Denison and universe Chicago and
00:12:00.240 --> 00:12:10.680
Diane Swonk: He was having to go into lockdown. And she was trying to get him back. So I was very aware of that and right away I started worrying. The minute that whoo. HON. I saw
00:12:11.010 --> 00:12:16.680
Diane Swonk: Whoo, hun shutting down. I knew there would be a supply chain effect on our manufacturers.
00:12:17.160 --> 00:12:31.440
Diane Swonk: And you know, we had gotten a little bit of a cushion because it was the Chinese New Year, and that our manufacturers had prepared for it. But as we got into February that clearly wasn't the case anymore. And then, of course,
00:12:31.980 --> 00:12:39.180
Diane Swonk: I had actually a meeting with my colleagues, we listened to a former Deputy Director of the CDC in the first week of February.
00:12:39.900 --> 00:12:51.570
Diane Swonk: And it was terrifying. And that really listening to this epidemiologist go through what is likely to happen and then seeing it spread around the world.
00:12:52.290 --> 00:12:57.870
Diane Swonk: By the by February we were already by latter part of February coin and and economic pandemic.
00:12:58.320 --> 00:13:02.820
Diane Swonk: And I was really stunned by, you know, people I know very well I advise the Federal Reserve.
00:13:03.210 --> 00:13:15.600
Diane Swonk: And how much they were discounting it right through the latter part of February, even as we were seeing, you know, Silicon Valley started out being the first ones to cancel in person meetings and
00:13:15.900 --> 00:13:21.540
Diane Swonk: You know, you could go into a restaurant, no one was there. I mean it was you could feel it and
00:13:22.380 --> 00:13:33.570
Diane Swonk: That even in the latter part of February, but that moment of watching it and then talking to a friend that was trying to get her son out of China with this family thinking you be safer here.
00:13:34.140 --> 00:13:43.170
Diane Swonk: And he lives in Shanghai not will home, but they also went into lockdown. And he was in lockdown with those two small children, very small children, one a newborn
00:13:43.920 --> 00:13:52.380
Diane Swonk: A friend that got trapped with them and his peasant in laws that are from that are from farm area.
00:13:52.860 --> 00:14:02.940
Diane Swonk: At all in a very small space for a very long period of time and she was worried about him. Now he has more freedoms to move around. No other freedoms.
00:14:03.270 --> 00:14:10.380
Diane Swonk: But he's living in very different kind of life than we are. And so, you know, all that anxiety that I went through with her on the phone and thinking about
00:14:10.680 --> 00:14:23.580
Diane Swonk: Immediately what did that mean to our production supply chain. And how would that affect us because as much as people talk about reassuring and bringing manufacturing back all the tariffs that we saw with China.
00:14:24.570 --> 00:14:30.420
Diane Swonk: One, they were born by consumers and by the producers in the US, we paid the price not China.
00:14:30.780 --> 00:14:40.890
Diane Swonk: And it didn't change the manufacturing equation we. It was very hard for companies to decouple from China and in fact they stayed and so
00:14:41.310 --> 00:14:52.350
Diane Swonk: That was going to be a direct effect we knew on our own background our own backyard economy and for me thinking about we deal with a lot of middle market manufacturers that was going to be a big issue for a firm as well.
00:14:53.520 --> 00:14:56.400
richardgreen: So there there was. There's so much there to talk about. So
00:14:56.790 --> 00:14:58.380
richardgreen: Let me try to keep track of.
00:14:58.470 --> 00:15:07.200
richardgreen: A number of things you said let's start with the fact that I think you should underline really important point is for for governments were shutting us down.
00:15:07.230 --> 00:15:09.150
richardgreen: We were shutting ourselves. Yeah.
00:15:09.720 --> 00:15:11.280
Diane Swonk: So, yeah.
00:15:12.840 --> 00:15:16.260
Diane Swonk: And I want to jump on that because that's
00:15:17.310 --> 00:15:20.220
Diane Swonk: The most important point, I know you understand it, Richard, but
00:15:21.120 --> 00:15:29.280
Diane Swonk: The course of the virus determines the course of the economy. Full stop. This is not something you can decouple and say, you know what will not have lockdowns
00:15:29.970 --> 00:15:39.510
Diane Swonk: You know, Austin goals be who I know you know did a really good study all the real time studies on this have been amazing, but by county looking at lockdowns and number of covert cases.
00:15:39.840 --> 00:15:50.040
Diane Swonk: And actual visits to establishment and areas that did not enforce lockdowns and did not enact lockdowns had the same kind of
00:15:50.910 --> 00:16:01.080
Diane Swonk: Loss and economic activity. Once you add it in case loads and hospitalizations and those local county caseload and occupied hospitalizations.
00:16:01.440 --> 00:16:04.980
Diane Swonk: Got particularly baby boomers, which are a third of consumer spending.
00:16:05.400 --> 00:16:12.060
Diane Swonk: They pull back and they stopped showing up at restaurants they stopped showing up at places that had public venues. They stopped showing up.
00:16:12.330 --> 00:16:21.690
Diane Swonk: Where you would exactly expect them to for fear of contagion. And we know from Ebola and SARS and mers that to be behavioral effects are the largest ones.
00:16:21.990 --> 00:16:38.820
Diane Swonk: And you know, I go back to that period where I was seeing an economic pandemic before it was a full global pandemic. But what's really important is between February 16 and march 14 march 19 is when the state of California went into their shutdown.
00:16:39.840 --> 00:16:47.460
Diane Swonk: Before that occurred before one state went into full lockdown. We lost 1.4 million jobs.
00:16:48.390 --> 00:16:59.880
Diane Swonk: In the latter part of February early March because of behavior firm institution canceling of conferences stop going to restaurants stop when the doctors talking to Dennis.
00:17:00.180 --> 00:17:12.690
Diane Swonk: And the loss in health, it was, it was a tremendous loss and the last in health care, which was once considered a recession proof part of the economy was extraordinary. Because people were afraid to go to the doctor.
00:17:14.280 --> 00:17:18.210
richardgreen: So along those lines is, as you know, my wife's a physician and
00:17:18.630 --> 00:17:22.320
richardgreen: One of the things she's finding now is her patients are
00:17:22.350 --> 00:17:23.520
richardgreen: Very, very sick.
00:17:24.090 --> 00:17:28.020
richardgreen: And it's not because of covert it's because they had to come in when they really should have come in.
00:17:28.320 --> 00:17:31.470
richardgreen: Right earlier and they've they've waited to the point where it's
00:17:31.740 --> 00:17:39.060
richardgreen: A harder to do something, then it would have been earlier on. So yeah the the impact of this and so many dimensions is so
00:17:39.720 --> 00:17:48.060
richardgreen: Extraordinary um I do. And the other thing is I want to just tell the class, right. One of my favorite of many favorite
00:17:48.840 --> 00:17:57.780
richardgreen: Data sources is Open Table reservation. It's you can look at how well the restaurant business is doing. And again, not all reservations get made to Open Table, but it's probably not a
00:17:57.900 --> 00:18:01.320
richardgreen: Bad representation of what's going on in the business and you can see
00:18:02.370 --> 00:18:09.480
richardgreen: How far we are behind not as bad as things were a couple of months ago beach restaurants have done a pretty good job of adjusting by
00:18:10.080 --> 00:18:15.210
richardgreen: Doing outdoor dining and so on, but still nowhere near back to where we were before.
00:18:15.810 --> 00:18:24.720
richardgreen: I want to come back to your point about the supply chain. So as I said that your the statement before the last one you had like four things I wanted pursuit. So let's talk about supply chain a little bit
00:18:25.620 --> 00:18:26.430
Diane Swonk: And
00:18:27.180 --> 00:18:30.420
richardgreen: You know, one of the problems with efficiency is it creates
00:18:30.420 --> 00:18:36.210
richardgreen: Fragility so um I don't know if you know Torsten slok
00:18:36.690 --> 00:18:37.770
richardgreen: But he was at
00:18:37.950 --> 00:18:39.300
richardgreen: Deutsche Bank for
00:18:39.360 --> 00:18:40.590
richardgreen: A number of years has just moved
00:18:40.590 --> 00:18:40.860
00:18:41.970 --> 00:18:47.460
richardgreen: And he had one of my favorite statistics which is the share of American manufacturing products that have
00:18:47.610 --> 00:18:50.640
richardgreen: A Chinese part of them one or more Chinese ports.
00:18:51.660 --> 00:18:53.190
richardgreen: And it's something like 60%
00:18:54.150 --> 00:19:09.090
richardgreen: So now, in some cases, it's one part. So if you look from a value added standpoint, you kind of look at the Chinese inputs from evaluation standpoint, you could go kind of we can deal with that. But of course, if that one part is missing from the manufacturing
00:19:09.090 --> 00:19:13.860
richardgreen: Process, you have to shut down your factory. You need to find another source.
00:19:14.220 --> 00:19:22.590
richardgreen: Of that park which reflects both reliance on China, but also just the leanness of the supply chain, which is something
00:19:22.590 --> 00:19:24.840
richardgreen: That people were trying to get to.
00:19:25.110 --> 00:19:29.160
richardgreen: That was the goal of management right just in time inventory
00:19:29.160 --> 00:19:29.730
00:19:31.020 --> 00:19:33.030
richardgreen: Do you see a transition now.
00:19:33.480 --> 00:19:45.570
richardgreen: Where our managers thinking more about long run as opposed to short run costs, build a little bit of redundancy into the supply chain. So if one part of it goes down there is, in fact, another
00:19:45.570 --> 00:19:54.030
richardgreen: Place that they can go or you think we're going to go back to the way we were, you know, let's say, three years post Copa, something like that.
00:19:54.360 --> 00:19:59.010
richardgreen: And we're going to have these lean production processes that are very fragile.
00:19:59.340 --> 00:20:09.600
Diane Swonk: To these sorts of events. Well, this isn't the first time, climate change is a big issue for supply chains as well. And you think of the tsunami that hit Japan, many years ago.
00:20:10.020 --> 00:20:16.380
Diane Swonk: And earthquakes that they've had there. There is one key part that literally almost shut down all of the auto industry.
00:20:17.070 --> 00:20:24.630
Diane Swonk: Because it came out of Japan. It was electronic part and, you know, these are these are things that have been with us for a while.
00:20:24.990 --> 00:20:32.310
Diane Swonk: It's interesting for me I smile because, you know, my background is in the auto industry. My dad worked in the auto industry and my dad was a
00:20:33.180 --> 00:20:46.170
Diane Swonk: He actually dealt with inventories and he was in charge of getting having 90 day inventories in the 1970s to Justin time inventories. And one of the interesting
00:20:46.680 --> 00:20:57.330
Diane Swonk: There's two stories that were very telling to me yet. We didn't stop the trends. So that's also telling in the 1980s. My father, they still they wanted to shut down his fax machine.
00:20:57.840 --> 00:21:06.030
Diane Swonk: And he was an international supply chain manager and they want to shut down this fax machine because it didn't understand it was expensive, and he's like,
00:21:07.320 --> 00:21:12.090
Diane Swonk: I need accountants are running GM at the time and at some Roger Smith was that
00:21:12.840 --> 00:21:14.100
richardgreen: A lot of FGS
00:21:14.670 --> 00:21:15.390
richardgreen: Absolute. Yes.
00:21:15.960 --> 00:21:25.470
Diane Swonk: I mean, here he had, you know, suppliers, all over the world. But London places they were, they had a supplier was South Korea and they were that's when South Korea was just beginning, it sort of industrial
00:21:25.710 --> 00:21:31.500
Diane Swonk: Revolution and becoming a major manufacturing player on the National Front in the 1980s.
00:21:31.800 --> 00:21:39.630
Diane Swonk: And at one point in time. The South Korean workers went on strike and shut down the plant and there wasn't one windshield.
00:21:39.870 --> 00:21:48.450
Diane Swonk: What was called the minds of vehicle in the United States In the United States to go into the car, not one in the country. And so my dad had to hire
00:21:48.810 --> 00:22:00.900
Diane Swonk: A group of people to go rob the factory in the middle of night, and then a 747 to fly a bunch of windshields to the United States. So they could be put into cars, instead of kind of undermines your costs.
00:22:01.170 --> 00:22:06.690
Diane Swonk: Of just in time to arm the inventories when you're doing that. Another thing that happened was,
00:22:07.320 --> 00:22:13.230
Diane Swonk: You know my dad worked to get down to inventories that were just in time like within hours right and
00:22:13.680 --> 00:22:23.850
Diane Swonk: Kind of ironic. The Lord's town Ohio plant in the 1990s. Today it's been shut down the alerts time Ohio GM plant was a key plant.
00:22:24.240 --> 00:22:30.360
Diane Swonk: And when the UAW wanted to strike GM they figured out, they could shut down all of GM by striking only one plant.
00:22:30.720 --> 00:22:42.690
Diane Swonk: And then Jim would have to pay all their other workers and that was the Lord's town plant and within a few hours, all of GM was shut down. So the fragility was both internal and external and just in time inventories.
00:22:43.470 --> 00:22:52.500
Diane Swonk: That said it's costly to have a cushion. And so what many companies are talking about his regionalisation not reassuring per se, but
00:22:52.770 --> 00:23:05.460
Diane Swonk: You know, playing off of the US MCA now instead of NAFTA and using Mexico as a platform, frankly, a lot of stuff that was to try to avoid terrace was shipped through Mexico into the US, that's another thing that occurred.
00:23:06.300 --> 00:23:19.080
Diane Swonk: As we saw the tariffs go on with China, but I think there's an important moral of the story as much as you try to do that. It doesn't really matter even if you did store inventories or not.
00:23:19.950 --> 00:23:25.200
Diane Swonk: It didn't matter if you were producing in one state versus another state in the United States. You still got shut down.
00:23:25.740 --> 00:23:36.150
Diane Swonk: You still had a supply chain problem. So if your supplier in, you know, California shut down and you were producing in Iowa. You couldn't you couldn't do anything.
00:23:36.690 --> 00:23:47.940
Diane Swonk: So I think, you know, my view is that the cost aspect of it is going to still dominate and we're going to have to deal with the reality of fragilities what
00:23:48.480 --> 00:24:03.000
Diane Swonk: We spent a lot of time on with our clients is logistics and one, you know, as they do this, what are the alternatives. So instead of, you know, not just another supplier. But how do you get it out. Another way as well.
00:24:04.050 --> 00:24:09.270
Diane Swonk: So it's not clear to me that we're going to see a lot more inventory is being held at the end of the day.
00:24:09.540 --> 00:24:10.620
richardgreen: Yeah, so, so
00:24:10.620 --> 00:24:15.420
richardgreen: Again, is that you don't see a large behavioral change as a result of
00:24:15.660 --> 00:24:28.020
Diane Swonk: YC lot more. Yeah, I see a lot larger changes in the broader economy that are both scarring and could be very, very detrimental to
00:24:28.770 --> 00:24:44.310
Diane Swonk: Our ability introductory on growth and composition and growth going forward. That's where I think the biggest effects of code that will be we're seeing a code recession that have risks metastasizing into a regular recession. It's longer lasting.
00:24:45.030 --> 00:24:49.140
richardgreen: And so then, so you segue into my next question here, which is
00:24:49.680 --> 00:24:57.120
richardgreen: What do you see as the law. And then I want to talk about policy, but what do you see are the long term impacts of this
00:24:57.390 --> 00:24:59.700
richardgreen: What will we not go back to
00:25:00.630 --> 00:25:09.180
Diane Swonk: Well you know a lot depends on us. I mean, right now, what we're risking by not having more aid from Congress. The Fed can only lend it cannot spend
00:25:09.840 --> 00:25:15.510
Diane Swonk: Is something. Jay, Paul has been days in congress sort of trying to clean to get more aid.
00:25:15.840 --> 00:25:26.010
Diane Swonk: The aid we had was extraordinary. In March of this year as the crisis unfolded, but now they think they're done. And the reality is that we're seeing.
00:25:26.340 --> 00:25:34.590
Diane Swonk: A real lost momentum you talked about Open Table. You know, we've looked at every all of those kind of high frequency data job postings of those kinds of things.
00:25:34.950 --> 00:25:44.430
Diane Swonk: After sharp bought bounce back we saw we lost momentum in late June, early on July as coda cases surged in the Sun Belt.
00:25:44.910 --> 00:25:52.860
Diane Swonk: But then we've also seen a resurgence of cases again and we're not seeing a pickup in momentum and the number Yelp.
00:25:53.220 --> 00:26:04.860
Diane Swonk: Has the number of small businesses that are permanently closed. Now that's accelerating. So the things I worry about is that we're going to have a more consolidated economy with a smaller base to rebuild from
00:26:05.250 --> 00:26:14.070
Diane Swonk: That is more concentrated in large firms that means less innovation less shared technology less
00:26:14.790 --> 00:26:24.600
Diane Swonk: Shared patents and things like that that spread to the overall economy more to just boost internal operations, rather than the overall economy.
00:26:25.410 --> 00:26:35.100
Diane Swonk: Less job generating ability going forward. That's one of the biggest issues on the supply side that I worry about that you're getting a supply shot.
00:26:35.460 --> 00:26:49.440
Diane Swonk: That firms, through no fault of their own, to quote. Jay, Paul, or the chairman of the Fed Jay is right that through no fault of their own, all of a sudden had an 80 year trend towards discretionary services turned on its ear by Kobe.
00:26:50.100 --> 00:26:59.790
Diane Swonk: So there's that aspect of it. Then there's the behavioral aspect of reaction, but also the scarring of the labor market, you've got, you know,
00:27:00.750 --> 00:27:12.270
Diane Swonk: We're gaining will probably gain about a million or less jobs in September. That seems like a lot, but when you're 11.6 million in the whole 25% more than the great recession.
00:27:13.410 --> 00:27:25.710
Diane Swonk: You whites are getting hired back at twice the pace of blacks the unemployment rate for 25 and over college grads, is that it's high is higher than it was a half percent higher than it was during the Great Recession.
00:27:26.190 --> 00:27:38.160
Diane Swonk: There is a bubble, we get in from work from home where we don't see the visceral damage, we're doing, you think about Millennials were hit by the Great Recession and now they're hit again.
00:27:38.550 --> 00:27:51.660
Diane Swonk: You think about Gen Z being hit is a graduate and it could compromise their earnings are talking about women being disproportionately hit when they have children and can't afford childcare and can't work from home.
00:27:52.800 --> 00:28:01.110
Diane Swonk: Those issues not able to feed their family food insecurity rising young children losing as much of a year of in person schooling.
00:28:01.500 --> 00:28:13.200
Diane Swonk: These are all really scarring effects that Hank have generational issues and exacerbate a coven revealed and magnified and equalities in an extraordinary way.
00:28:13.740 --> 00:28:26.370
Diane Swonk: And to not acknowledge that and also not learn from the mistakes we made in the wake of the 2008 2009 crisis by not doing enough aid in stimulus and by cutting it off too soon.
00:28:27.060 --> 00:28:34.830
Diane Swonk: We're making that same mistake now and it's really important. I often refer to code as the iceberg. And if we don't want to be the Titanic.
00:28:35.310 --> 00:28:46.500
Diane Swonk: We need to get lifeboats in the water with supplies true diverse coven tainted waters and that message seems to have gotten lost in translation on Capitol Hill.
00:28:47.790 --> 00:28:52.440
richardgreen: It will just to come to my silo for a moment. We
00:28:52.470 --> 00:28:53.280
richardgreen: We did a
00:28:53.730 --> 00:29:02.820
richardgreen: Three guys that UCLA, and I did a study over the summer where we surveyed how people were paying their rent and what we found. And this was in Los Angeles County.
00:29:02.880 --> 00:29:04.380
richardgreen: We surveyed 1000 people
00:29:05.430 --> 00:29:15.030
richardgreen: And the first thing we found is everyone who either didn't have lost their job or didn't have Kobe was paid their rent at the same rate that they were before.
00:29:15.390 --> 00:29:22.470
richardgreen: This despite the fact that we had an eviction moratorium and there was the story of about moral hazard and we saw no evidence that people who didn't face a
00:29:22.470 --> 00:29:33.840
richardgreen: Shock cease to pay their rent but but the other thing that was striking is among those that employed. Those who actually collected their unemployment were 60% less likely to miss a rent.
00:29:33.870 --> 00:29:36.480
richardgreen: Payment that those that have not yet.
00:29:36.960 --> 00:29:37.920
richardgreen: Had an employment.
00:29:38.130 --> 00:29:42.330
richardgreen: So the impact is not just on the recipients
00:29:42.420 --> 00:29:43.560
richardgreen: Of the age
00:29:43.710 --> 00:29:45.150
richardgreen: Of course, that's the most important
00:29:45.150 --> 00:29:47.490
richardgreen: Impact but you think about those landlords
00:29:49.050 --> 00:30:01.770
richardgreen: They have mortgages to pay. And so if you if they can't collect rent, then they can't pay their mortgage and you know there's been some forbearance done the multifamily Side But Not, not a whole lot
00:30:02.160 --> 00:30:06.390
richardgreen: And so it works through this chain that ultimately affects everybody
00:30:06.420 --> 00:30:07.080
richardgreen: And that's just
00:30:07.110 --> 00:30:13.230
richardgreen: one segment of the economy. And so I share your frustration that we haven't gotten money out to people.
00:30:14.160 --> 00:30:29.040
Diane Swonk: Well, and I mean you're the real estate expert in you know what strikes me is how the housing market sort of embodies the good, the bad, and the ugly of where we're at, because you got home sales and new home building surging
00:30:29.250 --> 00:30:37.680
Diane Swonk: Right now, you know, and at the highest level since 2006 which is, you know, was not the peak of the bubble, but still highest in 14 years
00:30:38.400 --> 00:30:47.670
Diane Swonk: We've waited for a long time to unleash this demand a lot of its second homes to their people who can are remodeling repairing upgrading
00:30:48.450 --> 00:30:58.710
Diane Swonk: You know, and buying second homes and people who are first time buyers, it can get out of urban areas are actually moving out of urban areas for the moment they're going to move. Anyway, so I think you know the
00:30:59.010 --> 00:31:03.990
Diane Swonk: We'll see what happens to urban cores, although I am concerned about some of the urban cores.
00:31:04.860 --> 00:31:13.650
Diane Swonk: But I think, you know, you see that going on and everyone says, oh, everything's great. But at the same time, the issues you're talking about the ability to pay rent.
00:31:13.920 --> 00:31:29.190
Diane Swonk: The impact on landlords, you know, and so many of those landlords, you know, or the smaller landlords that you know those can fall through the cracks so quickly. And a lot of them tend to a false disproportionate again on former immigrants.
00:31:29.220 --> 00:31:34.860
richardgreen: And minority communities, your left. You know, when black landlords or having worse collections and
00:31:35.220 --> 00:31:36.240
richardgreen: Waving yes or
00:31:36.690 --> 00:31:49.140
Diane Swonk: And so, you know, this is another. Do you see that any quality issue again on your, sort of, you know, in the housing market, which is being hailed as the silver lining and what is otherwise I
00:31:49.800 --> 00:32:01.680
Diane Swonk: clouded outlook clouded in uncertainty, at the very least, if we could, I mean think of what we can do in terms of reopening the economy, if we had rapid testing if we had, you know, coordinated, you know,
00:32:02.310 --> 00:32:11.730
Diane Swonk: Isolation and tracking efforts to be able to contain outbreaks, you know, Asia has done this, even in Vietnam quite more effectively than we have.
00:32:12.330 --> 00:32:17.760
Diane Swonk: wearing masks. It's not hard to do, you know, but to reopen the economy.
00:32:18.210 --> 00:32:26.550
Diane Swonk: We need to manage the virus and putting money federal money behind that is important. It's also important. Another issue of the aid that you know
00:32:26.910 --> 00:32:32.640
Diane Swonk: Including covering landlords, being able to pay the rent having these people being able to pay their rents to their landlords
00:32:33.090 --> 00:32:41.400
Diane Swonk: Is the issue of state and local governments. I mean, every State in the country has been hit by shortfall real on retail sales taxes shortfall in income taxes.
00:32:41.940 --> 00:32:47.580
Diane Swonk: And all of the you know cursory taxes they get from travel and tourism, it's gone.
00:32:48.210 --> 00:32:59.730
Diane Swonk: And that whole is a gap in whole that has nothing to do with which are blue states or red states or which states are better at managing their finances or not it's going to have a major
00:33:00.300 --> 00:33:08.880
Diane Swonk: headwind unemployment in state local employment one eight people in the country are employed by state local governments. It's down 1.1 million from February.
00:33:09.600 --> 00:33:17.190
Diane Swonk: Still today and on top of it. We're talking about compounding those headwinds by not doing transfers to the states.
00:33:17.400 --> 00:33:27.420
Diane Swonk: That was a major problem of the great recessions subpar employment recovery part it was housing couldn't come back after a housing bust and the subprime crisis.
00:33:27.900 --> 00:33:40.260
Diane Swonk: But a large part of it was the shortfall and tax revenues that real estate tax revenues that we saw the state and local level and the inability cuts in education, in particular, the inability to move forward.
00:33:40.620 --> 00:33:52.830
Diane Swonk: In employment in a way we usually did and we got set back again another leg headwind hit us in the expansion of the 2000 out of the recession of 2008 2009
00:33:53.280 --> 00:34:01.590
Diane Swonk: That's the lesson. That's another lesson that we can take and we say that was wrong. Let's not repeat it again. And that's exactly what we're doing right now.
00:34:02.610 --> 00:34:02.910
Diane Swonk: Okay.
00:34:02.940 --> 00:34:04.320
richardgreen: Our friend Claudia.
00:34:04.320 --> 00:34:18.360
richardgreen: Sam talks about this being some talks about this being aka shaped recovery, which I think is a really good metaphor, which is again explains why the housing market is doing well. But if you're a renter, you're, you're in pretty bad shape on other things I
00:34:18.540 --> 00:34:26.610
richardgreen: Think you made a comment that I want to follow up on because it was against so intriguing about basically just creating a more concentrated economy.
00:34:26.670 --> 00:34:30.570
richardgreen: As well, which means it will be less dynamic less competitive.
00:34:31.410 --> 00:34:35.640
richardgreen: And I think about this when I see the stock market. So the s&p 500 is worth
00:34:35.880 --> 00:34:38.130
richardgreen: About $27 trillion and people
00:34:38.130 --> 00:34:40.080
richardgreen: Are making a big deal out of, you know,
00:34:40.140 --> 00:34:40.860
richardgreen: Stock prices.
00:34:41.310 --> 00:34:42.060
richardgreen: Coming down some
00:34:42.390 --> 00:34:46.680
richardgreen: The last week, but of that 27,000,000,000,007 trillion of
00:34:46.680 --> 00:34:47.730
richardgreen: It is
00:34:47.790 --> 00:34:53.310
richardgreen: Apple, Amazon, Microsoft and Google so
00:34:54.600 --> 00:35:00.090
richardgreen: The brook the breadth of that it doesn't reflect a breadth of health that reflects that.
00:35:00.390 --> 00:35:02.550
richardgreen: A fairly small group of companies that
00:35:02.550 --> 00:35:04.080
richardgreen: Are specializing and things
00:35:04.080 --> 00:35:05.850
richardgreen: That people are really using
00:35:06.600 --> 00:35:07.470
Diane Swonk: Right now.
00:35:07.950 --> 00:35:10.860
richardgreen: As you know, I talked to over my
00:35:10.950 --> 00:35:12.660
richardgreen: Apple machine with
00:35:12.690 --> 00:35:13.260
richardgreen: I'm trying to think.
00:35:14.640 --> 00:35:19.380
richardgreen: Right. And I'm sure I've used Google about 53 times today and you get
00:35:19.740 --> 00:35:20.550
richardgreen: Get the idea
00:35:20.820 --> 00:35:21.360
00:35:22.680 --> 00:35:26.430
richardgreen: And I hadn't thought before though about that when you do think about
00:35:26.460 --> 00:35:32.850
richardgreen: Google being as big as it is, it's a problem and and it is, but it is also a dilemma because the reason. Google is so good.
00:35:33.630 --> 00:35:36.630
richardgreen: And if you go to China where Google isn't and you have to use
00:35:36.630 --> 00:35:37.710
richardgreen: Like bang you think
00:35:37.920 --> 00:35:39.150
richardgreen: This really sucks because if
00:35:39.270 --> 00:35:45.840
richardgreen: It does compared to Google. The reason Google so good is because they have our browsing habits for a zillion people
00:35:46.260 --> 00:35:55.830
richardgreen: So it's that sort of an enormous position they have it makes the product, good, but that almost certainly leads to other kinds of bad outcomes. And so how we
00:35:57.240 --> 00:35:58.620
richardgreen: Deal with both how we
00:35:58.650 --> 00:36:01.110
richardgreen: Keep the benefits of a Google
00:36:01.800 --> 00:36:05.730
richardgreen: Without compromising the dynamism, the economy. I think that's a
00:36:05.850 --> 00:36:06.570
richardgreen: Big time.
00:36:06.630 --> 00:36:14.370
Diane Swonk: Dilemma going forward. It's a huge dilemma came up in the Jackson Hole, Wyoming fed reserve meetings this year too and
00:36:14.910 --> 00:36:21.690
Diane Swonk: The consolidation. First of all, the dissonance between Wall Street Main Street. It was almost at times, as if Wall Street was whistling by the
00:36:22.110 --> 00:36:29.460
Diane Swonk: Graveyard literally in New York. I mean, it was stunning to see the dissonance and you know that, first of all, you touched on.
00:36:29.730 --> 00:36:39.360
Diane Swonk: The key issue of why that dissonance is there. First of all, the, the stock market indices brought industries are less reflective of the overall economy today than ever.
00:36:40.260 --> 00:36:48.570
Diane Swonk: The s&p 500 only covers about 20% employment in the US economy and it's long tech, the US economy is not long tech
00:36:49.200 --> 00:36:55.830
Diane Swonk: Market so long tech and so those few companies that have seen a lot of consolidation have an end.
00:36:56.340 --> 00:37:01.560
Diane Swonk: gobbled up some competitors have actually, you know, dominated the market.
00:37:01.890 --> 00:37:11.340
Diane Swonk: And that is part of the dissonance. The other part of the distances. Much of the pain. We're feeling is in small and middle market companies that are not listed on those indices
00:37:11.640 --> 00:37:22.320
Diane Swonk: trigger a small businesses where you see the pain that is not listed on those indices and if you sort of De de compact what's in the indices, you know, the factors that are driving it certainly isn't you know
00:37:22.860 --> 00:37:38.340
Diane Swonk: The airline producer or producers or the airlines right now on the travel and leisure industries been hard hit. And that's reflected in many of the stock prices, but also the Federal Reserve, the meltdown, we saw in the stock market and in the credit market, most notably
00:37:38.880 --> 00:37:52.560
Diane Swonk: In March was more rapid and worse than during the global financial crisis. I mean, I often say, like, you know, standing working in a financial firm during the global financial crisis was like standing on faultline
00:37:53.040 --> 00:38:06.150
Diane Swonk: Working this crisis was like standing on quicksand. I mean, the pace at which everything was deteriorating was just sort of unbelievable. And I also think that stock market volatility is what prompted Congress to come up with a bipartisan solution so quickly.
00:38:07.380 --> 00:38:15.330
Diane Swonk: Which is sad because Wall Street is not mean Street, the stock market is not the economy, but it does is a
00:38:15.990 --> 00:38:28.530
Diane Swonk: You know, lead indicator of consolidation and what could be a much less dynamic economy and what we're already seeing has been for all the technological innovation, we've had, which is amazing.
00:38:29.670 --> 00:38:35.250
Diane Swonk: We've seen very little productivity growth in the US economy. And it's not just a measurement problem.
00:38:35.280 --> 00:38:36.660
richardgreen: We've learned after about
00:38:36.660 --> 00:38:37.800
Diane Swonk: That yeah
00:38:38.370 --> 00:38:39.240
richardgreen: Measurement issue.
00:38:39.840 --> 00:38:48.240
Diane Swonk: Right. And, you know, some, but it just can't explain the slowdown. We've seen and we know that technology.
00:38:48.540 --> 00:38:59.340
Diane Swonk: Companies that embrace technology actually add jobs, they don't lose jobs. It's other companies that then lose jobs that can't embrace the new technology, but it also is
00:38:59.910 --> 00:39:09.090
Diane Swonk: Technology is best us not to replace workers per se, but to leverage bridge the skills gap. And that's often something that gets lost in translation because
00:39:09.510 --> 00:39:14.610
Diane Swonk: Companies too often. I've seen companies embrace the technology before they know how to use it.
00:39:15.360 --> 00:39:25.110
Diane Swonk: And do it with the sole goal of reducing their workforce when they realize they need more support people to support the technology or they don't know how to use it. I mean, it's really kind of ridiculous what happens
00:39:26.190 --> 00:39:34.290
Diane Swonk: So those are really important things as well. And I think, you know, when I, when I think about this one of the largest issues is
00:39:35.040 --> 00:39:41.190
Diane Swonk: What kind of economy will we have to return from on the other side of this and
00:39:41.730 --> 00:39:54.570
Diane Swonk: You don't want to have the scarring on our complexion through the labor market. You don't want to lose so much dynamism that you not only affect the composition of what we're spending on but you lower the trajectory of growth.
00:39:55.050 --> 00:40:02.550
Diane Swonk: That's what I'm worried about. It's not just regaining what we lost. We have to get back on a trajectory that wasn't terrific before
00:40:04.200 --> 00:40:10.680
richardgreen: Well, and this is particularly important in real estate because if you look at how real estate is valued. It's not just the current return. It's the
00:40:10.680 --> 00:40:11.340
00:40:11.820 --> 00:40:20.460
richardgreen: Of red and in the current environment where cap rates are four to 5% of 1% reduction in growth. That doesn't mean
00:40:20.700 --> 00:40:26.550
richardgreen: Negative growth just means a 1% reduction in growth means your values fall by like
00:40:26.580 --> 00:40:27.930
00:40:28.980 --> 00:40:32.670
richardgreen: And I think that that flows through did any kind of company you're
00:40:32.670 --> 00:40:40.950
richardgreen: Going to think about. So we're coming up on 40 minutes and I probably get you out of your 40 minutes, but I would like to ask you two more questions. If you have time
00:40:40.980 --> 00:40:42.630
richardgreen: Okay with us for a little bit longer.
00:40:43.080 --> 00:40:50.370
richardgreen: And and for whatever your, your audience. Oh, no, no, no, no, no, this is good. This is going by very quickly.
00:40:52.500 --> 00:41:01.230
richardgreen: The first is, is a more specific question. The second, I'm going to finish with a broad question, but but the specific get the financial sector in general.
00:41:01.830 --> 00:41:17.370
richardgreen: On the one hand, you look at banks they look like they're really well capitalized. I had reason to look at JP Morgan's balance sheet. The other day for a not really important reason. But they have like 12% capital, which is, you know, somebody would say is a really well capitalized bag and
00:41:17.760 --> 00:41:20.880
richardgreen: The other big banks aren't quite as good but they're they're quite good.
00:41:21.930 --> 00:41:23.130
richardgreen: But we also have
00:41:23.310 --> 00:41:25.830
richardgreen: Trivia returned to the shadow banking sector.
00:41:26.550 --> 00:41:28.590
richardgreen: Lots of finance being done.
00:41:28.620 --> 00:41:32.430
richardgreen: Through non bank institutions non deposit based
00:41:32.460 --> 00:41:34.140
richardgreen: Institutions so
00:41:34.170 --> 00:41:36.870
richardgreen: You know, how do you look at the health of the financial sector.
00:41:37.290 --> 00:41:38.490
richardgreen: Broadly, and this is an
00:41:38.490 --> 00:41:40.470
richardgreen: Issue, that's pretty important to the students in
00:41:40.860 --> 00:41:49.620
richardgreen: This class because it's it's what financial information about mortgages. It's basically what we study. So your views on that would be very helpful.
00:41:50.190 --> 00:42:04.800
Diane Swonk: Yeah. You know, it's interesting because first of all, yes, we, you know, the stress test the Fed went through in June for us to banks to raise their capital ratios and some banks do not give dividends as well.
00:42:05.610 --> 00:42:10.770
Diane Swonk: And the Fed is very concerned about future losses from this consolidation. The other side of those
00:42:11.040 --> 00:42:25.560
Diane Swonk: Which disproportionately hits community banks and some of the shadow banking sector, of course, more than it hits some of the larger banks, which are much more willing to the larger companies that can get access to funds in a different way. So,
00:42:26.730 --> 00:42:35.730
Diane Swonk: One. Yes, the banks are well capitalized, but I am worried about the losses, the legacy losses associated with this one through real estate.
00:42:36.000 --> 00:42:51.270
Diane Swonk: You know, we've seen Corbett is an accelerant on bankruptcies in retail also in shale industry. So you're going to see regional bank stress from those things as well, but also many of the non bank.
00:42:52.080 --> 00:42:53.190
Diane Swonk: The collateral damage.
00:42:53.970 --> 00:43:03.150
Diane Swonk: Of these down to non banks of people being unemployed with a lower I mean people consolidated their credit and pay down their credit cards, when they had even even
00:43:03.360 --> 00:43:11.040
Diane Swonk: You don't have as much subprime as they once did that they consolidated they're dead as the payments were higher on the supplemental to unemployment insurance.
00:43:11.430 --> 00:43:19.770
Diane Swonk: Now that that's gone. They can't do that. They did have some saving it actually increased they're saving and their cushion, which helped to get them through August
00:43:20.040 --> 00:43:26.820
Diane Swonk: But that's gone as we get into September and you really fall off a cliff. Once the money that
00:43:27.270 --> 00:43:33.540
Diane Swonk: The Executive Order tap the FEMA funds to get some people $300 a week. It's only last about three to four weeks.
00:43:33.870 --> 00:43:39.600
Diane Swonk: And then it's over. And it's dated back to August, you get one lump sum check. Once you get it, and that's it.
00:43:39.900 --> 00:43:52.320
Diane Swonk: But it really is important because it means we're adding more and more stress, particularly to the shadow banking system or whatever you want to call it fintech at this point in time in a way that
00:43:53.190 --> 00:43:59.250
Diane Swonk: We really, it's not in a way, we've known before because we could have very long term unemployment.
00:43:59.550 --> 00:44:06.360
Diane Swonk: The people transitioning to permanent employment from temporary is actually gone up, even as the unemployment rate has fallen in the
00:44:06.720 --> 00:44:17.880
Diane Swonk: As the economy tried to recover and that kind of scarring to people's financial records means they're going to lose access to, you know, mortgage markets and other kinds of credits so
00:44:18.270 --> 00:44:32.040
Diane Swonk: I do think that there is going to be some fairly large repercussions of this, but it's, you know, like a year, kind of a delay, maybe a year from the start. So, March of next year we'll start to see some of the carnage of those
00:44:32.430 --> 00:44:43.020
Diane Swonk: But it really is a huge. I think it is the it's something the Fed is very concerned about because they it's happening again in the part that they don't know proceed.
00:44:43.770 --> 00:44:52.260
Diane Swonk: And it's hard to get visibility. They're trying to get visibility as much as possible, friend of yours, a friend of mine, Raphael Bostic and Atlanta fed
00:44:52.770 --> 00:45:02.850
Diane Swonk: First thing he did is fintech has a big you know operations. They have a group in Atlanta. He said, I want to be on your group because I want to know what's going on because it's that important.
00:45:03.300 --> 00:45:13.980
Diane Swonk: And getting a lens into fintech and you know all the ways that it can affect us is really important to the Federal Reserve because it's even more.
00:45:14.790 --> 00:45:27.540
Diane Swonk: One, I think it's even more obscure than shadow banking was. And it's also has different ways of affecting us because many fintech things like applications were a bank gives you the ability to
00:45:28.260 --> 00:45:43.320
Diane Swonk: As opposed to demo, but a bank, you know, takes an application from an outside party. That gives another way to hack into a bank and that's another thing we didn't even talk about but cyber security. I mean, the hacks of sword. I can tell you, well, you know, as
00:45:43.890 --> 00:45:45.420
richardgreen: Nothing else to do. So they're
00:45:45.870 --> 00:45:46.350
Diane Swonk: They're doing
00:45:46.380 --> 00:45:59.820
Diane Swonk: Nothing else to do. And there's other governments also attack. You know, so you take the domestics that have nothing else to do, and have more time at home in front of their computers to hack us and my son is a computer science major and he's quite
00:46:00.240 --> 00:46:03.870
Diane Swonk: I mean, he's telling me all the different ways that he can hack me and he has actually
00:46:06.510 --> 00:46:11.010
Diane Swonk: He's also a stand up comedian. But that's not going so well at the moment, giving you can't stand up and
00:46:11.490 --> 00:46:13.890
richardgreen: Do the murder fund. I am so he can't get
00:46:14.370 --> 00:46:23.610
Diane Swonk: That yeah I yeah yeah exactly. He has done things to me. It's been all in just but it's scary.
00:46:23.940 --> 00:46:30.330
richardgreen: No, no, yeah, there is a lot that's that scary out there. I do want to, you know, I think.
00:46:30.870 --> 00:46:38.490
richardgreen: Again, if I want to underscore this issue of access to credit in the aftermath. In fact, currently, and one of the things I find frustrating.
00:46:39.630 --> 00:46:42.810
richardgreen: Is if you look at the black white homeownership gap.
00:46:43.350 --> 00:46:48.240
richardgreen: It can be explained in part from treatment that goes back to the 1930s, with the homeowners well
00:46:48.270 --> 00:46:54.600
richardgreen: Corporation when white people got to keep their houses black people didn't because white people got the relief.
00:46:54.600 --> 00:46:55.650
richardgreen: Of black people didn't
00:46:56.460 --> 00:47:04.140
richardgreen: We are now in a period that is a remarkable period for buying a house is with mortgage rates at 3% invest
00:47:04.170 --> 00:47:05.310
richardgreen: Lots of the country.
00:47:05.700 --> 00:47:08.430
richardgreen: On a cash flow basis, it is cheaper.
00:47:08.460 --> 00:47:10.200
richardgreen: To buy than it is to rent.
00:47:10.590 --> 00:47:19.440
richardgreen: And then you have upside as well. The problem, of course, this unless you have a job right now. And in particular, a salary job but W two job.
00:47:19.650 --> 00:47:23.250
richardgreen: You're not getting access to this credit. So it's like we're doing Lather, rinse.
00:47:23.250 --> 00:47:28.860
richardgreen: Repeat the same problem just comes back over and over and over again. And we can't seem to figure that
00:47:30.420 --> 00:47:38.160
Diane Swonk: It's the any quality on homeownership is going to get so much worse as a result of this crisis, we know
00:47:38.700 --> 00:47:51.870
Diane Swonk: Actually, I just saw Redfin had their economist come out and talk about the gap between white and black homebuyers right now and it has widened quite dramatically. And that's because
00:47:52.470 --> 00:48:04.770
Diane Swonk: Black households have been hit much harder by this crisis and, of course, white households, even in low age are getting higher back faster. I mean, this is we we've measured this and economics. We know it's systemic
00:48:05.730 --> 00:48:18.360
Diane Swonk: And you've seen it, you've looked at it in real estate. We know where all of these things come from it. We need to. This is where I'll try to be a little more positive to end, end up on
00:48:19.320 --> 00:48:39.900
Diane Swonk: This moment in time has crystallized what's wrong and what ails us, which is much more than coded and if we can use it as a catalyst to fix the things that Alice to create more inclusive growth instead of exacerbating even worse, the problems that were already there.
00:48:41.040 --> 00:48:53.430
Diane Swonk: Which is exacerbated by coven to take this as a moment to address those issues is better for the overall economy, as well as for the individuals that have been so marginalized.
00:48:53.820 --> 00:49:08.100
Diane Swonk: And Citibank just did a study where they estimated just since 2000 the last 20 years that the US economy has fallen 16 trillion sure where it would be because of inequality.
00:49:08.820 --> 00:49:09.630
richardgreen: Blacks and Whites.
00:49:10.800 --> 00:49:15.810
Diane Swonk: That stunning and I don't think that's probably
00:49:17.130 --> 00:49:18.060
Diane Swonk: an underestimate.
00:49:19.200 --> 00:49:28.170
Diane Swonk: We know that more inclusive growth is better for potential overall and i know i mean as economist we've struggled to try to
00:49:29.040 --> 00:49:41.490
Diane Swonk: put a number on how this is costing us because that's seems to be the only thing that people realize. But it's not hard to see how much it's costing us and that's where I have
00:49:41.760 --> 00:49:42.600
richardgreen: Some hope.
00:49:42.930 --> 00:49:48.810
Diane Swonk: That this is a catalyst for change. But that means we know it means this is my my
00:49:50.310 --> 00:49:55.530
Diane Swonk: My talk of get out the vote, you know, we know that representation that's more representative
00:49:55.890 --> 00:50:07.740
Diane Swonk: When it's occurred has been economic studies done when it's occurred it shown that when people are elected that more reflect the overall population, you get more egalitarian.
00:50:08.280 --> 00:50:16.950
Diane Swonk: Kinds of laws and then when there's a backlash to that and you throw those people out. You go back to where you were on the red lining and all the things that you know you know about
00:50:17.460 --> 00:50:24.630
Diane Swonk: Particularly in real estate and what's recently come out in hosing appreciation, you know, an in home appraisals where you know if you have
00:50:24.690 --> 00:50:37.140
Diane Swonk: Pictures of your family on the walls, you get a lower appraisal. I mean, it's a stunning stuff so you know this. These are really. I hope this is a catalyst and
00:50:37.860 --> 00:50:51.570
Diane Swonk: I hope we have people that vote to vote. People that resemble them more into office in this election in that's I guess the best note to end on, given where we're at.
00:50:51.870 --> 00:51:01.800
richardgreen: Yeah, so on that sober yet somewhat hopeful note, thank you for taking some time with us today. Diane always great to have a conversation with you.
00:51:02.310 --> 00:51:02.490
00:51:03.360 --> 00:51:06.750
richardgreen: I always wind up smarter at the end of it and
00:51:07.830 --> 00:51:08.340
richardgreen: I hope
00:51:08.430 --> 00:51:09.960
richardgreen: We can have you again. Sometime
00:51:10.620 --> 00:51:11.160